This past weekend my best friend, Kelsey Kaufman, was in town. I had a few things planned for us and one of those was baking a pumpkin pie. Neither of us had ever made a pie before, let alone pumpkin, but Kels had watched her mother a time or two and picked up some tips along the way.
We went grocery shopping and Kelsey led me to the sweet pumpkins in the produce section. Without her expertise in groceries, I would have mistakenly purchased a jack-o-lantern pumpkin and had poor results, no doubt. After picking up a few other necessities for the crust and filling, we were back and ready to start in our tiny kitchen. Following a recipe from allrecipes.com, we:
1. split the pumpkins in half
2. scooped out the insides (saving the seeds!)
3. peeled the skin
4. chopped into chunks
Next, we put the pumpkin chunks into a big pot and covered them with water. Bringing the pot to a boil, we continued to cook the pumpkin until the pieces were fairly tender (boiling the whole time). In the meantime, we made our pie crust. We stuck to your standard crust - flour, salt and good ol' shortening, plus some other stuff... Kels was in charge of that. The main tips I learned with pie crust were these:
1. cut in the shortening (or butter, if using that instead). If you don't have the proper utensil (I didn't) use two knives and make parallel cuts into the dough, going in the opposite directions (i.e. right hand cutting away from the center to the right, left hand cutting away from the center to the left, simultaneously).
2. once you've added enough water to moisten the dough, kneed with your hands, but not too much.
3. flour a counter or pastry mat and place the ball of dough directly on it. flour a rolling pin and begin to roll out the dough. once you've got close to 1/8 inch thick dough, grab your pie pan (or cake pan, if you don't have a pie pan... like me :) )
4. place the pan, face down, in the center of your dough. measure about an inch or two out from the pan and cut the dough in a circle around the pan. remove the excess pieces but save them to bake! * just add a little cinnamon and sugar and put on a cookie sheet to make a bonus treat :)
5. flour the dough a bit, then using the rolling pin, roll the dough onto the rolling pin, then unroll into the pan. SO innovative!! i would have never thought to do it without Kels.
6. using a fork, make indentations into the dough on the top of the pan, removing any excess dough that might be hanging off (and add those to the bonus pieces with cinnamon and sugar)
You're ready for the filling!!
To make the filling, we blended the chunks of pumpkin (literally in our blender). You can also mash the chunks - they're soft enough to even use a big fork, if that's the best utensil you have. Then add the rest of the standard ingredients - nutmeg, cinnamon, ginger, etc. (I'll include recipes later) We made the mistake of blending all these ingredients too well... it was literally a liquid. You might want to stir by hand and then proceed to fill the crust and bake.
One last key note, we were unsure when the pie was done. Especially since we had such a liquidy start, it was tough to tell. Unlike cakes and breads where you test the middle for solidity, with pumpkin pie you test an inch away from the edge; the pie is done when a knife comes out clean.
We took the pie to a party last night and it was a total hit! I haven't been that proud of my cooking/baking in a while, or at least it seems like a while since earlier this week was so rough...
Until next time :)